Breaking a Trust: What Does That Mean and Can It Be Done? 

Trusts serve several important purposes such as protecting assets, minimizing taxes, and providing benefits over both the short and long term. While there are many advantages to setting up a trust, that’s not my focus today. Instead, I want to address a question I’m often asked: Can a trust be broken? And if so, how easy is it? Let’s dive in. 

Different Perspectives: Creator vs. Beneficiary 

When someone asks me whether a trust can be broken, their perspective often reveals what they really mean. For example, if the question comes from the person creating the trust, they’re usually concerned about being locked into something without flexibility, either in the short term or the long term. And they want to be confident their goals will be achieved. 

“Short term” often refers to the next few years or even the rest of the creator’s lifetime. On the other hand, “long term” usually means the next generation and beyond. Ultimately, the creator wants to feel confident that the trust will fulfill their goals, both now and in the future. 

When a beneficiary asks whether a trust can be broken, it’s often because the trust no longer achieves the goals of the person who created it. Or, at least, that’s how the beneficiary feels. And that is likely the case if the trust is creating unnecessary burdens or complications for those it was meant to benefit. While the perspectives of the creator and the beneficiary may differ, the heart of the question is the same: How can we ensure that the trust continues to fulfill the creator’s goals? 

When a Trust No Longer Works 

So when we’re faced with problems in a trust, the first question we must ask is: What were the goals of the person who created it? Can we determine what they truly intended? Did they want to maintain control even after death? Were they hoping to create a lasting legacy? Perhaps they wanted to protect an inheritance for future generations or were concerned about a specific beneficiary who might misuse assets. Or maybe their goal was something else entirely. 

Although the answer to those questions may vary from situation to situation, one thing is clear: when a trust is no longer working as it should, it needs to be fixed. And we can fix it. 

An unwavering principle of trust and estate law is honoring the intent of the person who created the trust. So if a trust is no longer fulfilling its purpose or achieving the creator’s goals, are we truly serving them by letting it continue unchanged? In fact, if a trust no longer carries out the wishes of its creator, can we really say it’s still functioning as a valid trust? In that sense, when someone asks whether a trust can be broken, I often ask myself if breaking the trust is actually fixing it so that it once again serves its original purpose. Ultimately, isn’t that what we all want—for our plans to work, our goals to be achieved, and our wishes to be honored? When someone takes the time to create a trust, our mission should be to ensure that their intentions are fulfilled, even if that means we must make changes along the way. 

Pathways to Fix or Terminate a Trust 

As you can tell, there is much to the question of whether a trust can be “broken” or, as I might put it, fixed. And the good news is, there are pathways to do just that. When considering how to fix a trust, the goals and wishes of its creator must be considered. We want to know what they hoped to achieve. Understanding that intent helps us evaluate whether the trust, as it stands, is still doing what it was meant to do. 

Sometimes, minor alterations and adjustments are the pathway to fixing a trust. But in other cases, minor alterations and adjustments are insufficient. The problems may be too significant, and the only effective solution may be a complete termination of the trust and distribution of its assets to the beneficiaries identified in the trust. Although it may seem a drastic measure, that option should never be ignored. In fact, it may be the best and only solution to achieve the creator’s goals. So, full termination must always be on the table and considered an available option, especially when it doesn’t cause undue harm to the beneficiaries or the creator’s goals. 

So, if a trust needs to be fixed, how do we do it? Is it easy? Does it take a lot of time? Does it require going to court? Is it costly? 

These are all reasonable questions, and the answers will vary depending on the specific trust, its purpose, the state’s law, and the wishes of the person who created it. But ultimately, whether the process is simple or complex, fast or time-consuming, inexpensive or costly—fixing a trust will be worth it. 

If you’re the trustee of a trust that needs fixing, let’s talk. If you’re a beneficiary of a trust that needs fixing, let’s talk. If you’re aware of a trust that needs fixing, let’s talk. You’re not stuck. Contact us. We can help.  

Share this article and follow us on Facebook for more insights and updates. 

KT Williams Law PLLC | Serving Families in Estate Planning, Probate, and Estate Administration